As a teacher, I often differentiate between willingness and ability when it comes to the effort of my students. Sometimes students with academic challenges do everything asked of them, but they aren’t as able to succeed as other students. Students who are capable of doing the required work but choose not to, have a willingness issue. The students who set the bar for their classmates are those that are both able and willing when it comes to working.
The same terms might be said for reading. In the recently published book, The Book Whisperer, author Donalyn Miller identifies three types of readers: developing readers, dormant readers, and underground readers.
Developing readers, also labelled as struggling readers, may exhibit the following lack of ability:
- don’t read at grade level
- have great difficulty in understanding all types of reading
- often have participated in supplemental reading instruction or tutoring
- receive low standardized test scores, possibly even failing at least one state assessment
- believe they are unable to be a strong reader.
Dormant readers (also known as reluctant readers), though able to read, show a lack of willingness when it comes to reading. They may:
- read in order to pass their classes
- generally do well on state tests
- never read outside of school
- only read when they “have to”
- view reading as work rather than pleasure
- see no joy in reading
- not see the magic in books the same way they do in video games or tv programs
- have never connected with a book that magically takes them away, offers an escape into an unknown world, or allows them to vicariously experience characters’ lives.
Underground readers, sometimes referred to as gifted readers, show both willingness & ability when it comes to reading. They are usually capable and avid readers, however, they:
- see required school reading as completely disconnected from reading they prefer to do on their own
- just want to read and have teachers get out of their way
- finish an class-wide assigned book in days or a week, while it is assigned and taught in weeks or months
- find most of the assigned reading texts are well below their reading level – or perhaps, interest level
- finish classroom work quickly, so they can read an independent reading book.
All these types of readers should be a concern to us. Studies have shown that developing readers spend significantly less time reading, thus widening the gap even further as each school year progresses. Similarly, if dormant readers only read when required to do so during school hours, they also run the risk of falling behind other students who read more than they do. If underground readers do not stay challenged, they may become bored and be less willing to continue reading, an activity that they innately enjoy, and may come to view it as a chore.
What can we do as parents? First, determine where your child falls on the spectrum of readers.
Quite simply, developing readers need support in learning reading strategies, along with the chance to feel success as readers. Most importantly, they need an opportunity to read and read. When such children are given the opportunity to self-select books and read independently, paired with explicit instruction in reading strategies, they can transform as nonreaders into readers.
Similarly, dormant readers should be given the freedom to make their own reading choices, and ample opportunity to read. They also need to see reading for pleasure modeled.
Underground readers rarely give teachers trouble. Strong readers tend to be high academic achievers. Therefore, depending upon your child’s age, you should either intercede on your child’s behalf or coach him or her on being a self-advocate. See if the teacher is willing to compromise: As long as the student’s performance does not slip, is it acceptable during class to read a self-selected book while other students are finishing up work? May the student read ahead in class-wide novels as long as he or she agrees not to spoil the story’s outcome for the rest of the class? May he or she choose higher-level reading material that may contain more adult content as long as parental consent is communicated?
Fortunately, there are ways to help our children enjoy reading without requiring legislative changes or increases in already-tight school budgets. As parents, we can encourage our kids to read. Better yet, we can read with them or alongside them to model how reading can be pleasurable. We can take our children to the library and peruse the bookshelves, guiding their selections, but ultimately letting them self-select their reading material. When they express interest in certain titles, we can give them books as gifts.
In our fast-paced lives, what better way to spend some “quality” time than curled up on the couch with our children, reading a magazine, newspaper, novel or whatever we enjoy reading for pleasure?